
![]()
ESOP Discount Is Not a Paper Expense! ITAT Reaffirms Business Deduction in JSW Infrastructure Case
When employees receive shares at a concessional price, is the discount merely a notional loss for the employer? Mumbai ITAT reiterates that ESOP discount represents employee compensation and may qualify as business expenditure.
Introduction
Employee Stock Option Plans (ESOPs) have become an important component of employee remuneration, particularly in companies seeking to attract, motivate and retain talented employees. Under an ESOP, employees are given an opportunity to acquire shares of the employer company at a predetermined exercise price, which may be lower than the fair market value of the shares on the date of exercise.
The tax treatment of the discount involved in such arrangements has, however, been a subject of considerable litigation. The Revenue has often questioned the employer’s claim for deduction on the ground that the discount is notional, does not involve an actual cash outflow and represents a shortfall in the share premium.
The Mumbai Income Tax Appellate Tribunal has recently revisited this issue in JSW Infrastructure Limited v. Principal Commissioner of Income Tax-5, Mumbai, ITA No. 6051/Mum/2026, for AY 2020-21, order dated 23 September 2026.
The Tribunal upheld the legal position that ESOP discount represents employee-compensation expenditure incurred for business purposes. It also held that the Assessing Officer’s acceptance of the deduction, supported by binding judicial principles, could not be treated as erroneous merely to invoke revisionary jurisdiction under Section 263.
What Is an ESOP Discount?
Suppose a company grants its employees an option to purchase its shares at ₹100 per share. On the date of exercise, the fair market value of the share is ₹400.
The employee pays ₹100 and receives a share worth ₹400. The difference of ₹300 represents the benefit arising to the employee under the ESOP arrangement.
From the employer’s perspective, this discount is part of the compensation package offered to employees for their services and continued association with the company.
The accounting standards governing share-based payments require the employer to recognise the relevant employee-compensation cost over the vesting period, subject to the applicable accounting requirements.
The important question is whether such expenditure can also be recognised for income-tax purposes.
Facts of the JSW Infrastructure Case
JSW Infrastructure Limited had claimed ESOP expenditure of ₹7,27,74,000 in its return of income for AY 2020-21.
The return was selected for scrutiny, and the assessment was completed under Section 143(3) read with Section 144B on 27 September 2023.
Subsequently, the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax issued a show-cause notice under Section 263 proposing to revise the assessment order. One of the issues raised was the allowability of the ESOP expenditure.
The PCIT’s objection was that the expenditure represented a notional loss arising from the issue of shares at a discount and was, therefore, not allowable under Section 37(1).
The assessee explained that ESOPs were granted as an integral part of employee remuneration, with the objective of attracting and retaining competent personnel and aligning their interests with the company’s long-term growth. The discount was a quantified employee-compensation cost and was recognised in accordance with Ind AS 102.
The assessee also relied upon the Special Bench ruling in Biocon Ltd. v. DCIT and subsequent High Court decisions supporting the deductibility of ESOP expenditure.
The PCIT nevertheless set aside the assessment order for fresh examination, prompting the assessee to approach the ITAT.
The Legal Principle: ESOP Discount Is Employee Compensation
The Tribunal examined the nature and purpose of ESOP arrangements.
It observed that the primary object of granting ESOPs is to compensate employees for their services and secure their continued efforts during the vesting period. The discount embedded in the options is a method of quantifying and providing that compensation.
The Tribunal noted that there is no fundamental difference, for this purpose, between paying an employee an incentive in cash and compensating the employee by granting shares at a concessional price.
The fact that the expenditure is not immediately discharged in cash does not automatically make it notional. A definite commercial obligation towards employees can constitute expenditure even where its discharge is deferred or takes a non-cash form.
Accordingly, the discount cannot be treated merely as a short receipt of share premium or as capital expenditure simply because the arrangement involves the issue of shares.
The Biocon Special Bench Decision: The Foundation of ESOP Deduction
The legal foundation for allowing ESOP discount as business expenditure was laid down by the Special Bench of the Bangalore ITAT in Biocon Ltd. v. DCIT [2013] 35 taxmann.com 335 (Bangalore – Trib.) (SB).
The Special Bench held that the discount on ESOPs represents employee-remuneration expenditure and is allowable under Section 37(1), subject to the conditions prescribed therein.
The decision recognised that the discount is incurred for obtaining employee services and is not merely a notional loss arising from the issue of shares.
The Karnataka High Court subsequently affirmed the decision in CIT v. Biocon Ltd. [2021] 430 ITR 151 (Karnataka).
The principle has also been followed by other High Courts, including:
– PVR Ltd. v. CIT [2022] 145 taxmann.com 331 (Delhi High Court).
– CIT v. Shriram City Union Finance Ltd. [2024] 460 ITR 232 (Madras High Court).
These decisions provide substantial judicial support for the employer’s claim that ESOP discount, properly quantified and incurred as employee compensation, is deductible business expenditure.
What Did the Mumbai ITAT Decide in JSW Infrastructure?
The Revenue argued that the ESOP expenditure was recognised over the vesting period, whereas the employee’s right to acquire shares and the corresponding perquisite taxation arose only when the options were exercised. It also contended that no actual payment had been made to the employees.
The Tribunal did not accept this reasoning.
It held that the timing of taxation of the perquisite in the employee’s hands does not determine the character or allowability of expenditure in the employer’s hands.
Section 17(2)(vi) deals with the taxation of the ESOP benefit as a perquisite in the employee’s hands. Section 37(1), on the other hand, governs the deductibility of business expenditure in the employer’s hands.
The two provisions operate in different statutory fields and address different taxpayers. The employee’s liability to tax on exercise of the option cannot be treated as the governing test for deciding the employer’s expenditure claim.
The Tribunal observed that the Assessing Officer’s acceptance of the ESOP claim was supported by the Special Bench ruling in Biocon and subsequent High Court decisions. The PCIT had not identified any distinguishing feature that would take the assessee’s case outside those judicial principles.
Consequently, the Assessing Officer’s view could not be characterised as unsustainable in law merely because the PCIT held a different opinion.
The Tribunal rejected the PCIT’s invocation of Section 263 in relation to the ESOP expenditure.
An important distinction: The appeal before the ITAT concerned revisionary proceedings under Section 263. The Tribunal was examining whether the assessment order accepting the ESOP deduction could lawfully be revised. The decision should not be described as laying down that every ESOP claim, irrespective of its facts and supporting evidence, must automatically be allowed.
Employer’s Deduction and Employee’s Taxability: Two Separate Questions
A common source of confusion is the difference between the tax treatment of ESOPs in the employer’s hands and the employee’s hands.
1. In the employer’s hands
The discount represents employee-compensation expenditure. Where the expenditure satisfies the applicable statutory requirements and is properly quantified and supported, it may be claimed as business expenditure.
For assessment years governed by the Income-tax Act, 1961, the relevant general deduction provision is Section 37(1).
2. In the employee’s hands
Under the Income-tax Act, 1961, the difference between the fair market value of the shares on the date of exercise and the amount paid by the employee is generally taxable as a perquisite under Section 17(2)(vi), subject to the applicable provisions.
Thus, the employer’s deduction and the employee’s perquisite taxation are independent tax consequences. The fact that the employee is taxed on exercise does not, by itself, postpone or determine the employer’s deduction.
Important Change Under the Income-tax Act, 2025
The Income-tax Act, 2025 came into force on 1 April 2026, replacing the Income-tax Act, 1961.
Accordingly, tax professionals must identify the relevant assessment year or tax year before applying the statutory provisions.
Applicable law| Relevant provision
Income-tax Act, 1961| Section 37(1) – General business expenditure
Income-tax Act, 2025| Section 34(1) – General conditions for allowable deductions
Section 34(1) of the Income-tax Act, 2025 allows expenditure laid out or expended wholly and exclusively for the purposes of business or profession, subject to the exclusions and conditions prescribed in that Act.
Therefore, for tax years governed by the new Act, Section 34(1) should be examined instead of referring to Section 37(1) of the old Act.
The change in statutory numbering should not be confused with a change in the underlying principle that genuine employee-compensation expenditure may qualify for deduction when the statutory conditions are fulfilled.
Documents and Checks Before Claiming ESOP Expenditure
A company claiming deduction for ESOP expenditure should maintain proper documentation and ensure that the claim is supported by the underlying scheme and accounting records.
The following documents and details deserve particular attention:
1. Board resolution approving the ESOP scheme and relevant shareholder approvals, wherever required.
2. Copy of the approved ESOP scheme and its terms and conditions.
3. Employee-wise details of options granted.
4. Grant date, exercise price and fair market value valuation.
5. Vesting schedule and details of options vested.
6. Details of options exercised, forfeited, cancelled or expired.
7. Accounting entries and working papers supporting the ESOP expense.
8. Reconciliation between the expense recognised in the books and the deduction claimed in the income-tax computation.
The accounting treatment under Ind AS 102 or other applicable accounting standards should be examined carefully. The tax deduction should be supported by a proper computation and should not simply be copied from the accounting expense without examining the relevant tax principles.
Special Caution: ESOPs Granted by a Parent Company to Subsidiary Employees
A separate examination is necessary where the parent company grants ESOPs to employees of its subsidiary and subsequently recovers the corresponding expenditure from the subsidiary through a cross-charge arrangement.
The tax position of a company issuing its own shares to its employees and that of another company bearing the expenditure relating to options granted by its parent company should not automatically be treated as identical.
The nature of the arrangement, the employment relationship, the contractual obligation, the basis of the cross-charge, the actual accounting treatment and the business purpose of the expenditure must be examined independently.
A deduction should not be claimed merely because an amount has been debited to the profit and loss account or charged by a group company.
Conclusion: ESOP Discount Is Compensation, Not Merely a Discount on Shares!
The decision in JSW Infrastructure Limited reinforces an important principle in ESOP taxation: the economic substance of an ESOP arrangement must be examined.
Where shares are offered to employees at a concessional price in consideration of their services, the discount represents a component of employee remuneration. The absence of an immediate cash outflow does not, by itself, convert the expenditure into a notional or capital loss.
The Special Bench decision in Biocon, affirmed by the Karnataka High Court and followed by other High Courts, provides the judicial foundation for this position. The Mumbai ITAT has now reiterated that an assessment allowing such expenditure in accordance with the prevailing judicial position cannot be revised merely because the PCIT prefers a different view.
For tax professionals, the message is clear: Examine the employer’s deduction and the employee’s perquisite taxation separately. Identify the applicable tax law, verify the ESOP documentation, reconcile the accounting expense with the tax computation and apply the relevant judicial principles.
Case Reference: JSW Infrastructure Limited v. Principal Commissioner of Income Tax-5, Mumbai, ITA No. 6051/Mum/2026, AY 2020-21, order dated 23 September 2026.
Meta Description: Mumbai ITAT in JSW Infrastructure reiterates that ESOP discount is employee compensation and may qualify as business expenditure under Section 37(1), following Biocon.
The copy of the order is as under:




