GST on Assignment of Leasehold Rights and Land Development Cost: Andhra Pradesh AAAR Upholds Taxability in Kobelco Case, but High Court Subsequently Grants Stay

Loading

GST on Assignment of Leasehold Rights and Land Development Cost: Andhra Pradesh AAAR Upholds Taxability in Kobelco Case, but High Court Subsequently Grants Stay

 

 

In re: Kobelco Construction Equipment India Pvt. Ltd.

2026 (5) TMI 487 – Appellate Authority for Advance Ruling, Andhra Pradesh

AAAR Order No. AP/AAAR/07/2025 dated 2 December 2025

Introduction

Is assignment of long-term leasehold rights in land a taxable supply of service under GST, or should it be treated as a transfer of immovable property falling outside GST under Schedule III? Can reimbursement of the cost incurred towards land development, roads, drainage and other civil infrastructure also attract GST?

These questions were examined by the Andhra Pradesh Appellate Authority for Advance Ruling (AAAR) in In re: Kobelco Construction Equipment India Pvt. Ltd.

The Appellate Authority upheld the advance ruling that GST was payable on both the consideration received for assignment of unexpired leasehold rights and the separately recovered land development cost. It held that the transaction involved transfer of the right to use the property for the remaining lease period, rather than transfer of ownership of the land. It also treated the development-related recovery as consideration for identifiable construction and development services.

However, an important subsequent development must be noted. The Andhra Pradesh High Court, in W.P. No. 8018 of 2026, stayed the operation of the AAR and AAAR orders on 5 May 2026. Consequently, although the AAAR decision remains an important contribution to the GST debate, its operation in this particular dispute is subject to the High Court proceedings.

1.  Facts of the Case

M/s Kobelco Construction Equipment India Pvt. Ltd. was engaged in manufacturing excavators and had established its manufacturing unit at Sri City, Andhra Pradesh.

The land was owned by Sri City Private Limited, which had developed an integrated industrial park. A parcel of 9.35 acres forming part of the Domestic Tariff Zone was originally leased to Kobelco Cranes India Private Limited under a lease deed dated 29 May 2015 for a period of 99 years.

Following a corporate restructuring and merger, Kobelco Construction Equipment India Pvt. Ltd. held the leasehold rights in the property.

The company subsequently proposed to transfer the unexpired leasehold rights, together with the superstructure and improvements, to India Metal One Steel Plate Processing Private Limited, with the consent of the original lessor, Sri City Private Limited.

The consideration was divided into two components:

Particulars| Amount

Transfer of leasehold rights and property transfer value| ₹11,35,00,000

Recovery of land development cost| ₹4,03,00,000

Total consideration| ₹15,38,00,000

In addition, the transferor was required to pay a transfer fee or commission to the original lessor for permitting the transfer.

The company approached the Andhra Pradesh Authority for Advance Ruling to determine the GST implications of the proposed transaction.

2.  Questions Before the Advance Ruling Authority

The applicant sought a ruling on three questions:

1.  Whether assignment of leasehold rights in leasehold land would constitute a supply under Section 7 of the CGST Act, 2017, and whether GST would be payable on the consideration received.

2.  Whether recovery of land development cost and related expenses would constitute a supply of service liable to GST.

3.  Whether the applicant would be eligible to claim input tax credit of GST paid on the commission or transfer fee payable to Sri City Private Limited in connection with the transfer.

The AAR, by Order No. 07/AP/GST/2025 dated 6 August 2025, answered the questions in the affirmative.

Aggrieved by the ruling, the applicant preferred an appeal before the Appellate Authority for Advance Ruling.

3.  Assignment of Leasehold Rights: Is It Sale of Land or Supply of Service?

The applicant contended that leasehold rights are benefits arising out of land and constitute an interest in immovable property.

According to the applicant, assignment of such rights should be regarded as a transfer of immovable property and consequently covered by the exclusion relating to sale of land under Schedule III of the CGST Act.

The appellant relied upon the Gujarat High Court decisions in:

– Gujarat Chamber of Commerce and Industry v. Union of India [2025 (1) TMI 516 – Gujarat High Court].

– Dhiraj Can Co. (P.) Ltd. v. Union of India [2025 (7) TMI 622 – Gujarat High Court].

The appellant also relied upon the Supreme Court decision in Chief Commissioner of CGST v. Safari Retreats Pvt. Ltd. [2024 (10) TMI 286 – Supreme Court].

AAAR’s reasoning

The Appellate Authority rejected the contention and drew a distinction between ownership of land and the right to use land for a specified period.

It observed that what was being transferred was not ownership or title in the land itself. The original lessor continued to remain the owner. The transferor was merely assigning its right to use the demised premises for the remaining period of the lease.

The Authority relied upon Section 7 of the CGST Act, read with paragraph 2(a) of Schedule II, which treats a lease, tenancy, easement or licence to occupy land as a supply of service.

Accordingly, the Authority held that assignment of unexpired leasehold rights amounted to a transfer of the right to use immovable property for consideration and was taxable as a supply of service.

The distinction drawn by the AAAR is important: the exclusion relating to sale of land does not automatically extend to every transaction involving rights connected with land.

4.  Reliance on Gujarat High Court Decisions

The appellant placed considerable reliance on the Gujarat High Court decisions in Gujarat Chamber of Commerce and Industry and Dhiraj Can Co. (P.) Ltd.

The Appellate Authority observed that departmental appeals against the Gujarat High Court decisions had been admitted by the Supreme Court. It therefore considered that the decisions had not attained finality and declined to follow them.

The Authority also referred to earlier advance rulings from Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh and West Bengal, along with CBIC Circular No. 44/18/2018-CGST dated 2 May 2018.

These decisions and circulars were considered as persuasive interpretative material supporting the Revenue’s position that assignment of leasehold rights was taxable.

It is important to appreciate that the AAAR’s treatment of the Gujarat High Court judgments was part of its reasoning in this particular appeal. The subsequent High Court proceedings concerning the Kobelco transaction have also brought the conflict between the competing interpretations into focus.

5.  Why Safari Retreats Was Held Inapplicable

The appellant also relied upon the Supreme Court judgment in Chief Commissioner of CGST v. Safari Retreats Pvt. Ltd.

The Appellate Authority distinguished that decision on the ground that it concerned eligibility for input tax credit on construction of immovable property intended to be leased.

The issue before the AAAR was different. It concerned the taxability of assignment of existing leasehold rights and the consideration received for such assignment.

The Authority therefore held that the principles laid down in Safari Retreats did not determine the taxability of the leasehold assignment in the present case.

This distinction is important. A decision dealing with eligibility of input tax credit on construction of a building cannot automatically decide whether assignment of leasehold rights constitutes a taxable supply.

6.  Recovery of Land Development Cost: A Separate Taxable Supply

The second major issue concerned recovery of ₹4.03 crore towards land development cost.

The appellant had incurred expenditure on development and improvement of the demised premises, including:

– Construction and development of roads;

– Drainage facilities;

– Levelling of land;

– Compound walls;

– Allied civil infrastructure and facilities.

The appellant recovered these amounts separately from the transferee.

The appellant’s position was that the amount represented reimbursement of expenditure incurred in relation to the land and should not be treated as an independent supply of service.

AAAR’s reasoning

The Appellate Authority accepted the AAR’s conclusion that the development activities had an independent service character.

It observed that the activities were not merely incidental to the transfer of leasehold rights. They involved identifiable construction and development work which enhanced the usability and value of the premises.

The recovery was separately identifiable and distinct from the consideration for assignment of leasehold rights.

The Authority therefore treated the amount of ₹4.03 crore as consideration for construction and development services and held it liable to GST.

The Authority also referred to the CBIC clarification contained in Circular No. 177/09/2022-GST dated 3 August 2022, concerning the tax treatment of land development and related civil works.

The ruling highlights the importance of examining the actual nature of the activity for which a separate amount is recovered. Merely describing a receipt as reimbursement does not automatically take it outside the scope of supply.

7.  Input Tax Credit on Transfer Fee Paid to the Original Lessor

The third question concerned eligibility of input tax credit on GST paid on the commission or transfer fee payable to Sri City Private Limited for permitting the assignment of leasehold rights.

The AAR had answered this question in favour of the applicant, holding that the credit was available subject to the applicable provisions of the CGST Act.

The advance ruling on the three questions was challenged before the AAAR. The appeal was dismissed and the advance ruling was upheld.

The ITC issue should be considered separately from the taxability of the assignment itself. Eligibility of credit depends upon satisfaction of the statutory conditions under Section 16 and the restrictions, if any, under Section 17 of the CGST Act.

8.  AAAR’s Final Decision

The Andhra Pradesh Appellate Authority for Advance Ruling dismissed the appeal and upheld the AAR’s decision.

The conclusions were:

1.  Assignment of unexpired leasehold rights was treated as a taxable supply of service under Section 7 read with paragraph 2(a) of Schedule II.

2.  The transaction was distinguished from sale of land under Schedule III because ownership of the land was not transferred.

3.  The recovery of ₹4.03 crore towards land development cost was treated as consideration for separately identifiable construction and development services.

4.  The ruling of the AAR regarding input tax credit on the transfer fee was also upheld.

9.  Important Subsequent Development: Andhra Pradesh High Court Grants Stay

The AAAR decision cannot be discussed without referring to the subsequent proceedings before the Andhra Pradesh High Court.

Kobelco challenged the AAR and AAAR orders in Writ Petition No. 8018 of 2026.

On 5 May 2026, the High Court observed that the petitioner had relied upon the Gujarat High Court judgment in Gujarat Chamber of Commerce and Industry v. Union of India. The Court expressed the view that the advance ruling authorities could not have ignored the said judgment.

Accordingly, the High Court granted a stay of operation of both the AAR order dated 6 August 2025 and the AAAR order dated 2 December 2025.

The proceedings continued on subsequent dates, including 6 July and 3 August 2026.

Thus, the AAAR’s conclusion in favour of GST levy must be read subject to the High Court’s interim order. The High Court has not, by granting the interim stay, finally decided the underlying GST controversy.

This development is particularly important for taxpayers considering similar transactions. The AAAR ruling is an important authority on the Revenue’s interpretation, but the High Court proceedings mean that the legal position remains contested.

10.  Practical Implications for Businesses Holding Long-Term Leasehold Rights

The ruling raises several important compliance and transaction-planning issues.

1.  Examine the nature of rights being transferred

A transfer of ownership of land and assignment of a right to use land for the remaining lease period are legally different transactions. The documents and actual rights transferred must be examined carefully.

2.  Separate consideration for leasehold rights and development costs

Where development costs are recovered separately, the nature of the underlying activities should be documented. The tax treatment may differ depending upon whether the amount represents consideration for an independent service or forms part of another transaction.

3.  Do not rely only on the description ‘reimbursement’

An amount described as reimbursement may still constitute consideration for a taxable supply if it is linked to identifiable services rendered.

4.  Review the original lease deed

The original lease deed, restrictions on assignment, lessor’s consent, transfer charges and rights of the lessee are important in determining the nature of the transaction.

5.  Examine the latest judicial position

Since the AAAR orders have been stayed by the Andhra Pradesh High Court, businesses should consider the interim judicial position and any subsequent orders before taking a final GST position.

Conclusion

The decision in In re: Kobelco Construction Equipment India Pvt. Ltd. addresses two significant GST issues: assignment of unexpired leasehold rights and recovery of land development expenditure.

The Andhra Pradesh AAAR treated assignment of leasehold rights as a supply of service because only the right to use the land for the remaining lease period was transferred, and not ownership of the land. It also treated the separately recovered land development cost as consideration for identifiable construction and development services.

However, the subsequent interim stay granted by the Andhra Pradesh High Court is a crucial development and must not be overlooked while relying upon the AAAR ruling.

The larger issue remains whether assignment of leasehold rights should be treated as a taxable service or as transfer of a benefit arising out of immovable property. Until the High Court finally resolves the controversy, businesses undertaking such transactions should carefully examine the contractual structure, the nature of rights transferred and the prevailing judicial orders.

The copy of the order is as under:

ORDE R N0.AP1AAAR102-2O25




Share this article