DCF Is Out for Unquoted Equity Shares? Rule 57 of Income-tax Rules, 2026 Prescribes NAV Formula

Loading

DCF Is Out for Unquoted Equity Shares? Rule 57 of Income-tax Rules, 2026 Prescribes NAV Formula

 

A Major Change in Share Valuation: What Happens to DCF After Abolition of Angel Tax?

Introduction

For years, valuation of unquoted equity shares has been a subject of considerable debate between taxpayers and the Income Tax Department. One of the most important valuation choices available to companies issuing shares under the angel-tax provisions was the option to adopt either the Net Asset Value (NAV) method or the Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) method.

DCF was particularly attractive to start-ups and growing businesses because it recognised their future earning potential rather than restricting valuation to the book value of existing assets.

However, the valuation landscape has undergone an important change. With the abolition of angel tax under Section 56(2)(viib) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, and the introduction of the Income-tax Rules, 2026, the earlier DCF option has not been carried forward for valuation of unquoted equity shares under Rule 57.

Rule 57, effective from 1 April 2026, prescribes a specific NAV-based formula for unquoted equity shares. The change deserves attention from companies, start-ups, investors, tax professionals and valuation experts.

1.  The Earlier Position Under Rule 11UA

Under the Income-tax Rules, 1962, Rule 11UA provided different valuation mechanisms depending upon the nature and purpose of the transaction.

Two situations need to be distinguished.

A.  Valuation for transfer of unquoted equity shares

For the purposes of Section 50CA, read with Rule 11UAA and Rule 11UA, the NAV-based formula was prescribed for determining the fair market value of unquoted equity shares.

Thus, DCF was not an alternative valuation method for this transfer-related provision.

B.  Valuation for issue of shares under Section 56(2)(viib)

The position was different for issue of unquoted equity shares under the angel-tax provisions.

Rule 11UA(2), as amended by Notification No. 81/2023 dated 25 September 2023, permitted the company to adopt the prescribed valuation options. These included:

– NAV-based valuation; and

– DCF valuation determined by a merchant banker.

Additional valuation methods were also introduced for specified cases involving non-resident investors.

Consequently, DCF became an important valuation option for companies issuing shares at a premium, particularly start-ups whose commercial value was based more on future earning potential than on existing net assets.

2.  Abolition of Angel Tax: Section 56(2)(viib) Disappears

The Finance (No. 2) Act, 2024 abolished the angel-tax provisions contained in Section 56(2)(viib) with effect from Assessment Year 2025-26.

Accordingly, consideration received by a closely held company for issue of shares at a premium is no longer subjected to the earlier angel-tax provision from AY 2025-26 onwards.

The Income-tax Act, 2025, which came into force on 1 April 2026, has also not re-enacted the corresponding angel-tax provision.

This has an important consequence for valuation.

The special DCF option under Rule 11UA(2) was linked to the angel-tax provision. Once the charging provision itself was abolished, there was no corresponding requirement to carry forward that special valuation mechanism into the new rules.

The CBDT’s notified Income-tax Rules, 2026, therefore do not reproduce the earlier DCF option for unquoted equity shares.

3.  What Does New Rule 57 Prescribe?

Rule 57 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026 deals with determination of fair market value of specified assets for the purposes of Sections 26(2)(j), 72 and 92 of the Income-tax Act, 2025.

Item No. 4 of the table specifically deals with unquoted equity shares.

It prescribes the following formula:

Fair Market Value = (A + B + C + D – L) × (PV / PE)

Where:

– A = Book value of assets, excluding specified assets such as jewellery, artistic work, shares, securities and immovable property, after prescribed adjustments.

– B = Open-market value of jewellery and artistic work, supported by a registered valuer’s report.

– C = Fair market value of shares and securities determined under the prescribed rules.

– D = Value adopted, assessed or assessable for stamp-duty purposes in respect of immovable property.

– L = Book value of liabilities, excluding specified items such as paid-up equity capital, reserves and surplus, certain provisions and contingent liabilities.

– PV = Paid-up value of the equity shares being valued.

– PE = Total paid-up equity share capital as shown in the balance sheet.

The formula is substantially based on the NAV approach.

Unlike the earlier angel-tax valuation provision, Rule 57 does not provide a separate DCF option or an alternative income-based valuation method for unquoted equity shares.

This is the significant change introduced by the new rules.

4.  What About Transfer of Unquoted Equity Shares?

For transfers of unquoted equity shares, the statutory framework also needs to be understood carefully.

Section 79 of the Income-tax Act, 2025, which corresponds to Section 50CA of the earlier Act, provides that where consideration received or accruing on transfer of an unquoted share is lower than its prescribed fair market value, the prescribed fair market value shall be deemed to be the full value of consideration for the purposes of Section 72.

Rule 57 prescribes the NAV formula for unquoted equity shares for the purposes of Section 72.

Therefore, the NAV approach continues to be relevant for determining the deemed full value of consideration on transfer of unquoted equity shares.

It is important to remember that the transfer-related valuation position and the earlier angel-tax valuation position are two different matters. DCF was available as an option under the specific angel-tax framework; it was not an alternative to the prescribed NAV method for Section 50CA-related transfer valuation.

5.  What Happens to Legacy Angel-Tax Assessments?

The abolition of angel tax does not mean that all earlier angel-tax disputes automatically disappear.

The provisions of Section 56(2)(viib), read with Rule 11UA as applicable, continue to be relevant for earlier assessment years, particularly AY 2024-25 and preceding years, subject to the applicable limitation and transitional provisions.

Where a company had validly exercised the DCF option under the then-applicable Rule 11UA and obtained the prescribed valuation report, the Assessing Officer could not simply reject DCF and substitute NAV merely because the Assessing Officer preferred a different valuation approach.

Several judicial decisions have recognised this principle.

In Vodafone M-Pesa Ltd. v. PCIT (2018) 92 taxmann.com 73 (Bombay), the Bombay High Court examined the statutory valuation framework and the limits on the Assessing Officer’s power to interfere with the prescribed valuation method.

Similarly, in PCIT v. I.A. Hydro Energy (P.) Ltd. (2024) 163 taxmann.com 408 (Himachal Pradesh), the High Court upheld the principle that where the assessee had exercised the DCF option under Rule 11UA(2), the Assessing Officer could not substitute the NAV method merely because of differences between projected and actual financial results.

The Assessing Officer may examine the correctness of the assumptions and working in the valuation report, but cannot casually substitute a different prescribed method merely because the outcome is less favourable to the Revenue.

Thus, DCF continues to matter in legacy angel-tax litigation, even though the special option has not been carried forward under the new Rule 57.

6.  What About CCPS, Preference Shares and Other Non-Equity Instruments?

Another important aspect of Rule 57 is Item No. 5, which deals with unquoted shares and securities other than equity shares in a company.

For such instruments, the rule provides that fair market value shall be the price the instrument would fetch if sold in the open market on the valuation date.

The assessee may obtain a valuation report from:

– A merchant banker; or

– An accountant.

Unlike unquoted equity shares, Rule 57 does not prescribe a fixed NAV formula for these instruments.

It also does not expressly prescribe DCF as a mandatory or exclusive method. However, since the statutory benchmark is the open-market price, DCF may be considered as a valuation technique in an appropriate case, provided the valuation report reliably supports the price the instrument would fetch in the open market.

The distinction is important:

Instrument| Rule 57 valuation approach

Unquoted equity shares| Prescribed NAV formula

CCPS and other non-equity shares/securities| Open-market value, supported by merchant banker or accountant report

Other unquoted securities| Open-market value, supported by merchant banker or accountant report

Therefore, it would be incorrect to conclude that DCF has become universally impermissible for every kind of unquoted security. The new rule prescribes a specific formula for equity shares, while retaining an open-market valuation approach for other unquoted instruments.

7.  Practical Implications for Companies and Investors

The new valuation framework has several practical implications.

1.  Equity share valuation needs to be revisited

Companies issuing or transferring unquoted equity shares under provisions covered by Rule 57 should ensure that valuation is carried out using the prescribed formula.

2.  Historical DCF reports remain relevant for legacy cases

Companies facing angel-tax assessments for earlier years should preserve their original valuation reports, business projections and supporting documents.

3.  Preference shares require separate consideration

CCPS and other non-equity instruments should not automatically be valued using the NAV formula applicable to unquoted equity shares.

4.  Valuation documentation remains essential

Even where the rule prescribes NAV, proper preparation of the balance sheet, identification of assets and liabilities, and supporting valuation evidence remain important.

5.  DCF reports should not be used indiscriminately

For transactions governed by the new Rule 57, companies should first identify the precise category of instrument and the applicable statutory provision before selecting a valuation methodology.

Conclusion

The introduction of Rule 57 under the Income-tax Rules, 2026 marks an important change in the valuation framework for unquoted equity shares.

The earlier DCF option under Rule 11UA(2) was specifically connected with the angel-tax provisions under Section 56(2)(viib). Following abolition of that provision from AY 2025-26, the special DCF option has not been carried forward into the new rules.

For unquoted equity shares covered by Rule 57, the NAV formula is now the prescribed valuation mechanism. For CCPS, preference shares and other unquoted non-equity securities, the rule continues to rely on open-market value supported by an appropriate valuation report.

The important lesson is that DCF has not simply disappeared from the world of valuation. It has, however, lost its former status as an express statutory alternative for valuation of unquoted equity shares under the angel-tax framework. Under the new Rule 57, the nature of the instrument and the statutory provision governing the transaction will determine the permissible valuation approach.




Share this article