
![]()
Allotment Letter Creates a Capital Asset: ₹80 Lakh Buy-Back Surplus Cannot Be Taxed as Income from Other Sources
Ritu Wadhwa Makhija v. ACIT, Central Circle 5(4), Mumbai
ITA No. 3358/Mum/2026 | Assessment Year 2022-23 | ITAT Mumbai “D” Bench | Order dated 16 October 2026
Introduction
Does an allotment letter for a flat create a capital asset even where the purchaser has not executed a registered agreement or taken possession? Can the surplus received on cancellation or buy-back of such allotment rights be taxed as “Income from Other Sources” merely because the property was never registered in the assessee’s name?
The Mumbai Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal has answered these questions in favour of the assessee in Ritu Wadhwa Makhija v. ACIT. The Tribunal held that rights acquired under an allotment letter constitute a capital asset within the meaning of Section 2(14) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, and that the subsequent extinguishment of those rights for consideration amounts to a transfer under Section 2(47).
The Tribunal accordingly deleted the addition of ₹80 lakh assessed as “Income from Other Sources”. The decision reinforces the legal principle that ownership of a completed immovable property is not the only form of capital asset. Contractual rights to obtain conveyance of a property may themselves constitute a valuable capital asset.
Facts of the Case
The assessee, Ritu Wadhwa Makhija, filed her return of income for Assessment Year 2022-23 declaring total income of ₹29,56,480. She was associated as a promoter, shareholder, director or partner with entities forming part of the Wadhwa Group, engaged in real estate development.
The dispute arose in respect of Flat No. 602, Panorama Residency, Ghatkopar, Mumbai.
The assessee had booked the flat with M/s Wadhwa Residency Pvt. Ltd., a group concern, through an allotment letter dated 30 October 2017. The agreed consideration was ₹9.10 crore.
Against the agreed consideration, the assessee paid ₹4.80 crore on the date of allotment through banking channels. The balance of ₹4.30 crore was payable before taking possession.
Subsequently, on 20 March 2022, the developer bought back the flat for a consideration of ₹9.90 crore. The assessee claimed that the amount represented consideration for extinguishment of her rights arising from the original allotment.
The surplus of ₹80 lakh, being the difference between the buy-back consideration of ₹9.90 crore and the original agreed consideration of ₹9.10 crore, was offered as long-term capital gain. After claiming the cost of acquisition and indexation, the assessee declared capital gain of ₹58,824.
However, the Assessing Officer rejected the capital gains treatment. The officer observed that no registered agreement had been executed in the assessee’s name, possession had not been taken and the property continued to remain under the ownership and control of the developer.
The Assessing Officer also questioned the commercial substance of the transaction, considering that the assessee was associated with the developer.
Accordingly, the entire surplus of ₹80 lakh was assessed under the head “Income from Other Sources”, and the benefit of indexation was denied.
The CIT(A) upheld the addition. The assessee thereafter appealed before the ITAT Mumbai.
The Issue Before the Tribunal
The principal issue was whether the rights acquired by the assessee under the allotment letter constituted a “capital asset” under Section 2(14), and whether the subsequent buy-back or extinguishment of those rights amounted to a “transfer” under Section 2(47).
The Revenue’s contention was that the assessee had neither acquired ownership of the flat nor taken possession. Therefore, according to the Department, no capital asset had been acquired or transferred.
The assessee contended that the allotment letter, coupled with the substantial payment made towards the agreed consideration, created enforceable contractual rights in the property. The subsequent surrender of those rights for consideration was therefore a transfer of a capital asset.
Allotment Rights Can Constitute a Capital Asset
The Tribunal examined the allotment letter dated 30 October 2017 and the payment of ₹4.80 crore made by the assessee through ICICI Bank.
The allotment letter specified the agreed consideration of ₹9.10 crore and the date of allotment. The balance consideration was payable before possession.
The Tribunal considered the legal character of the rights acquired under the allotment letter. It observed that the definition of “capital asset” under Section 2(14) is wide enough to include valuable rights in a property, even if the assessee has not acquired registered ownership of the completed flat.
The Tribunal referred to the principle laid down in PCIT v. Vembu Vaidyanathan, decided by the Bombay High Court, and other judicial precedents recognising that rights arising from allotment of property can constitute a capital asset.
The relevant consideration is whether the allotment created identifiable and enforceable rights in favour of the assessee.
Thus, the absence of a registered conveyance or delivery of possession does not, by itself, negate the existence of a capital asset.
Extinguishment of Rights Is a “Transfer” Under Section 2(47)
Section 2(47) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, includes within the definition of “transfer” the extinguishment of any rights in a capital asset.
The Tribunal observed that if the allotment letter created enforceable rights in favour of the assessee, the subsequent surrender or extinguishment of such rights for consideration would fall within the ambit of Section 2(47).
In the present case, the allotment rights were acquired on 30 October 2017. The subsequent buy-back by the developer on 20 March 2022 resulted in the extinguishment of those rights for a consideration of ₹9.90 crore.
The Tribunal therefore held that the transaction was a transfer of a capital asset and that the resultant gain was assessable under the head “Capital Gains”, subject to the applicable provisions governing computation.
The Tribunal specifically rejected the Revenue’s contention that transfer of legal ownership of the completed flat was essential for the transaction to qualify as a transfer of a capital asset.
CBDT Circulars 471 and 672: Relevance of the Date of Allotment
The assessee also relied upon CBDT Circular No. 471 dated 15 October 1986 and Circular No. 672 dated 16 December 1993.
These circulars explain the treatment of allotment rights in specified housing schemes. The principle recognised therein is that where an allotment is final and the allottee has acquired rights upon payment of the first instalment, the date of allotment may be treated as the date of acquisition, subject to the terms of the scheme.
The Tribunal observed that the applicability of these circulars depends upon the similarity of the allotment scheme and the rights created thereunder, rather than merely upon the status of the allottee.
The Tribunal also noted that the assessee’s claim was independently supported by judicial precedents, including Tata Services Ltd., Vijay Flexible Containers and Mukesh Sohanraj Vardhan v. ITO.
Related-Party Transaction: Does Association With the Developer Make It a Sham?
An important aspect of the case was that the assessee was associated with the developer as a promoter, director or shareholder.
The Revenue contended that the arrangement lacked commercial substance and was a colourable device.
The Tribunal rejected this contention. It observed that association with the developer does not, by itself, negate the existence of rights acquired under an allotment letter. Nor does a transaction between related or associated parties automatically become a colourable device.
The allegation must be supported by relevant material demonstrating that the transaction lacked commercial substance or that the documents did not reflect the actual arrangement.
In the present case, the Tribunal considered the following evidence:
– Allotment letter dated 30 October 2017;
– Payment of ₹4.80 crore through banking channels;
– Agreed consideration of ₹9.10 crore;
– Subsequent buy-back for ₹9.90 crore;
– Correspondence relating to the buy-back.
In the absence of cogent evidence establishing that the documents were fictitious or that the transaction was a sham, the Tribunal held that the allegation of a colourable device could not be sustained merely because of the assessee’s association with the developer.
Tribunal’s Decision: ₹80 Lakh Addition Deleted
The Tribunal concluded that:
1. The rights acquired by the assessee under the allotment letter constituted a capital asset under Section 2(14).
2. The subsequent extinguishment of those rights upon buy-back amounted to a transfer under Section 2(47).
3. The absence of a registered agreement or possession did not, by itself, negate the existence of a capital asset.
4. The association of the assessee with the developer did not automatically establish that the transaction was a colourable device.
5. The surplus of ₹80 lakh could not be assessed as “Income from Other Sources” merely because the flat had not been registered in the assessee’s name.
The Tribunal held that the resultant gain was assessable under the head “Capital Gains”, subject to the applicable statutory provisions governing computation.
Accordingly, the addition of ₹80,00,000 made under the head “Income from Other Sources” and sustained by the CIT(A) was deleted.
The appeal of the assessee was allowed. The decision is recorded in paragraphs 33 to 35 of the Tribunal’s order.
Important Takeaways for Taxpayers and Real Estate Investors
1. Allotment rights may themselves constitute a capital asset
A valuable right to obtain conveyance of a flat may qualify as a capital asset, even if the purchaser has not yet acquired registered ownership.
2. Registration and possession are not the only tests
The existence of enforceable contractual rights under an allotment letter is relevant for determining whether a capital asset has been acquired.
3. Surrender of allotment rights can amount to a transfer
Extinguishment of rights for consideration falls within the definition of transfer under Section 2(47).
4. Buy-back surplus may be taxable as capital gains
The surplus received on surrender or buy-back of allotment rights may be assessable under the head “Capital Gains”, rather than “Income from Other Sources”.
5. Related-party transactions require evidence-based scrutiny
A transaction involving a group concern cannot be treated as a sham merely because the assessee is associated with the developer. The Revenue must establish the allegation with relevant material.
6. Documentation is crucial
Allotment letters, payment records, ledger accounts, correspondence and buy-back agreements are important evidence to establish the existence and extinguishment of rights.
Conclusion
The decision in Ritu Wadhwa Makhija v. ACIT reiterates an important principle of capital gains taxation: a capital asset need not necessarily be a completed property registered in the name of the assessee.
Rights acquired under a genuine allotment letter may constitute a capital asset under Section 2(14), and their subsequent extinguishment for consideration may amount to a transfer under Section 2(47).
The Tribunal has also clarified that the absence of possession or registration, and the association of the assessee with the developer, cannot by themselves justify treating the surplus as income from other sources.
The key takeaway is that the tax character of a property transaction depends upon the nature of the rights acquired and transferred—not merely upon whether the property was registered or possession was taken.
The copy of the order is as under:




