Section 272A(2)(e) Penalty Cannot Continue Beyond Section 139(4) Due Date: Chennai ITAT Restricts Period of Default

Loading

Section 272A(2)(e) Penalty Cannot Continue Beyond Section 139(4) Due Date: Chennai ITAT Restricts Period of Default

 

 

Swamy Vivekanandha Vidhyala Trust v. Income-tax Officer, Exemptions, Salem

IT Appeal No. 2108 (CHNY) of 2026 | Assessment Year 2013-14 | ITAT Chennai | Order dated 11 August 2026

Introduction

Can the Income Tax Department levy daily penalty under Section 272A(2)(e) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, for the entire period until an assessee files its return in response to a reassessment notice under Section 148? Or should the period of default be restricted to the last date on which the assessee could have furnished a valid return under Section 139(4)?

The Chennai Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal examined this issue in Swamy Vivekanandha Vidhyala Trust v. ITO (Exemptions), Salem. The Tribunal held that the penalty for failure to furnish the return of income cannot be computed beyond the last date prescribed under Section 139(4), merely because the return was subsequently filed in response to a notice under Section 148.

The decision provides significant relief to charitable trusts and other assessees who face substantial penalties for delayed filing of returns, particularly where the return is ultimately furnished only after reopening of assessment proceedings.

Facts of the Case

The assessee, Swamy Vivekanandha Vidhyala Trust, was a charitable trust running an educational institution and registered under Section 12A of the Income-tax Act, 1961.

The trust did not file its return of income for Assessment Year 2013-14. The Assessing Officer received information that the trust had deposited cash amounting to ₹75,55,200 in its bank account during the relevant year.

Since the return had not been filed, the Assessing Officer initiated reassessment proceedings by issuing a notice under Section 148 of the Act.

In response to the notice, the trust filed its return of income declaring Nil income after claiming exemption under Section 10(23C)(iiiad). The Assessing Officer completed the reassessment under Section 147, accepting the returned income.

Subsequently, the Assessing Officer initiated penalty proceedings under Section 272A(2)(e) for failure to furnish the return of income.

The assessee explained that the return was not filed due to a bona fide belief that, since its income was exempt, there was no requirement to file a return. It further contended that there was no loss of revenue and no intention to conceal income.

The Assessing Officer rejected the explanation and levied penalty of ₹3,04,300. The CIT(A) confirmed the penalty, holding that the failure to file the return was a statutory default and that the absence of revenue loss or mala fide intention did not absolve the assessee.

Aggrieved, the trust preferred an appeal before the ITAT Chennai. <Cite refs={[“turn484324search0″,”turn484324search2”]}/>

The Issue Before the Tribunal

The principal issue before the Tribunal was whether the penalty under Section 272A(2)(e) could be computed until the date on which the assessee filed its return in response to the notice under Section 148, or whether it had to be restricted to the last date available for furnishing the return under Section 139(4).

The Revenue contended that the default continued until the return was actually filed in response to the reassessment notice. According to the Department, the penalty was leviable for every day of failure until the return was furnished.

The assessee, on the other hand, argued that the statutory obligation to furnish a voluntary return could not be treated as continuing beyond the period during which a valid return could legally be furnished under Section 139(4).

Tribunal’s Analysis: Can a Default Continue When Compliance Is No Longer Legally Possible?

Section 272A(2)(e) provides for penalty for every day during which the failure to furnish the return continues.

The Tribunal examined the expression “during which the failure continues” in the context of the statutory scheme governing return filing.

It observed that the obligation under Section 139(4A) to furnish the return of income could be discharged only within the period prescribed under Section 139. Once the time limit under Section 139(4) expired, the assessee was no longer empowered to voluntarily furnish a valid return of income under that provision.

The Tribunal reasoned that, after expiry of the statutory period, the default could not be regarded as continuing merely because the assessee subsequently filed a return in response to a notice under Section 148.

The Tribunal emphasised that accepting the Revenue’s interpretation would result in the levy of penalty for a period during which the assessee had no statutory right to furnish a valid voluntary return. Such an interpretation would effectively treat the default as continuing even when the law itself did not permit the assessee to perform the obligation in the same manner.

The Tribunal invoked the well-established principle that the law does not compel a person to perform an impossibility.

Accordingly, it held that the period of default under Section 272A(2)(e) had to be restricted to the last date prescribed under Section 139(4), and not extended until the date of filing the return in response to Section 148. <Cite refs={[“turn484324search0″,”turn484324search3”]}/>

The Tribunal’s Direction

The Tribunal directed the Assessing Officer to recompute the penalty by restricting the period of default up to 31 March 2014, being the last date available to the assessee for furnishing the return of income under Section 139(4) for Assessment Year 2013-14.

The issue was remitted to the Assessing Officer for the limited purpose of recalculating the penalty in accordance with the Tribunal’s directions.

It is important to note that the Tribunal did not delete the penalty in its entirety. The relief was confined to the period for which the daily penalty could be calculated.

The appeal was partly allowed. <Cite refs={[“turn484324search0″,”turn484324search3”]}/>

Important Takeaways for Charitable Trusts and Taxpayers

1.  Penalty period cannot be extended indefinitely

The daily penalty under Section 272A(2)(e) cannot automatically continue until the date on which the return is filed in response to a reassessment notice.

2.  Section 139(4) provides the relevant outer limit

For calculating the period of default, the Tribunal held that the last date available under Section 139(4) is the relevant cutoff.

3.  Filing a return under Section 148 does not extend the original default period

The subsequent filing of a return in response to a reassessment notice does not, by itself, extend the period for computing the penalty under Section 272A(2)(e).

4.  The penalty may require recomputation

Where penalty has been calculated up to the date of filing the return under Section 148, taxpayers may examine whether the period should be restricted in light of this decision.

5.  The ruling is about the computation period, not complete immunity

The Tribunal restricted the period of penalty but did not hold that failure to file the return was entirely excused. The penalty was directed to be recomputed.

Conclusion

The decision in Swamy Vivekanandha Vidhyala Trust v. ITO (Exemptions) provides a meaningful interpretation of the expression “during which the failure continues” under Section 272A(2)(e).

The Tribunal has held that the period of default cannot be extended beyond the statutory time available under Section 139(4), merely because the return is subsequently furnished in response to a reassessment notice under Section 148.

The ruling is particularly relevant for charitable trusts which have not filed their returns despite claiming exemption and subsequently face reassessment and daily penalty proceedings.

The principle emerging from the judgment is that daily penalty cannot be imposed for a period beyond the statutory window in which the assessee could legally have furnished the return under Section 139(4).

The copy of the order is as under:

ITA No.2108-CHNY-2026




Share this article