
![]()
Section 54F Denial on Second Flat Does Not Make Its Entire Cost Taxable: Bombay High Court Corrects ₹4.78 Crore Addition
Nilesh Ramesh Modi v. Income Tax Officer, Ward 16(3)(1), Mumbai
Writ Petition No. 4898 of 2026 | Bombay High Court | Order dated 2 November 2026
Introduction
Can the Income Tax Department, after denying exemption under Section 54F of the Income-tax Act, 1961, in respect of the investment in a second residential flat, add the entire purchase cost of that flat to the taxpayer’s income? The Bombay High Court has highlighted the fallacy in such an approach in Nilesh Ramesh Modi v. Income Tax Officer.
The Court held that denial of exemption on the investment in the second flat does not mean that the entire cost of the flat becomes taxable income. Capital gains must be computed in accordance with the proportionate exemption formula prescribed under Section 54F(1)(b). The Court found the addition of ₹4.78 crore to be manifestly incorrect and substantially reduced the amount required to be deposited for obtaining a stay of recovery.
The ruling is particularly significant for taxpayers facing substantial demands arising from capital gains exemption claims, where the Assessing Officer’s computation may go beyond the actual capital gain chargeable to tax.
Facts of the Case
The assessee, Nilesh Ramesh Modi, transferred tenancy rights in two properties for an aggregate consideration of ₹2.30 crore during the previous year relevant to Assessment Year 2024-25. He also sold long-term capital assets in the form of shares for ₹8.75 crore and short-term shares for ₹1.69 lakh. The aggregate consideration from the transfer of capital assets was ₹11.07 crore.
The assessee entered into an understanding with the developers of Piramal Mahalaxmi, Mumbai, for purchasing two adjoining residential flats:
– Flat No. 4106: ₹4,88,82,168
– Flat No. 4107: ₹4,78,45,668
The assessee’s intention from the beginning was to use both adjoining flats as one residential house. The floor plan indicated that the units could be used together. However, the Revenue pointed out that separate agreements had been executed, that the flats had separate entrances and kitchens, and that the developer had described them as separate units.
The assessee claimed exemption under Section 54F in respect of the investments made in both flats. The Assessing Officer allowed the exemption only in respect of Flat No. 4106, together with the amount deposited in the Capital Gains Savings Scheme, and rejected the claim concerning Flat No. 4107.
The Assessing Officer, however, added the entire purchase consideration of ₹4,78,45,668 for Flat No. 4107 to the assessee’s income. The assessment was completed under Section 143(3) read with Section 144B.
The assessee filed an appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) and also sought rectification under Section 154. The rectification application was rejected. The stay application was disposed of by directing the assessee to deposit 20% of the outstanding demand, amounting to ₹38,75,018.
Aggrieved by the computation and the conditional stay, the assessee approached the Bombay High Court. <FileCite ref_id=”turn3file0″ line_range_start={72} line_range_end={102} /><FileCite ref_id=”turn3file0″ line_range_start={107} line_range_end={148} /><FileCite ref_id=”turn3file0″ line_range_start={152} line_range_end={227} />
The Core Issue Before the High Court
The principal question considered by the High Court was whether the entire cost of the second flat, for which exemption under Section 54F had been denied, could be added to the assessee’s income.
The Court made it clear that it was not deciding the merits of the assessee’s claim that the two adjoining flats could be treated as one residential house. The Revenue had contended that the amendment to Section 54F, effective from 1 April 2015, replacing the expression “a residential house” with “one residential house”, restricted the exemption to one residential house.
The Court expressly refrained from expressing an opinion on this controversy. It confined its decision to the incorrect computation of capital gains and the amount of tax payable for the purpose of deciding the stay of recovery. <FileCite ref_id=”turn3file0″ line_range_start={246} line_range_end={256} />
Section 54F: Exemption Is Proportionate, Not an Addition of the Entire Investment
Section 54F(1)(b) provides a proportionate exemption where the cost of the new residential house is less than the net consideration received from the transfer of the original asset.
The statutory formula is:
Exemption = Capital Gain × Cost of New Asset ÷ Net Consideration
Consequently, where an investment is not considered eligible for exemption, the computation must still be made in accordance with the statutory formula. The amount of investment denied as an exemption cannot automatically be treated as taxable income.
The High Court examined the computation furnished by the assessee in the affidavit-in-rejoinder. The capital gains computed by applying Section 54F(1)(b) amounted to ₹2,93,47,526. The Revenue’s counsel did not dispute this computation.
The Court observed that the addition of ₹4,78,45,668, representing the purchase consideration of Flat No. 4107, was manifestly incorrect. <FileCite ref_id=”turn3file0″ line_range_start = {260} line_range_end = {291} />
The Computation: How the Addition Went Wrong
The figures involved in the case demonstrate the importance of applying the correct statutory formula.
Particulars| Amount (₹)
Long-term capital gain before exemption| 10,37,84,171
Exemption claimed under Section 54F| 9,99,99,793
Capital gain as returned| 37,84,378
Cost of Flat No. 4107 added by the Assessing Officer| 4,78,45,668
Capital gain computed by applying Section 54F(1)(b)| 2,93,47,526
Excess addition resulting from the incorrect computation| 2,22,82,520
The Assessing Officer’s computation effectively increased the taxable capital gain by adding the entire cost of Flat No. 4107. However, the correct computation under Section 54F(1)(b), as placed before the Court and not disputed by the Revenue, resulted in capital gains of ₹2.93 crore.
The distinction is crucial. The denial of an exemption claim does not authorize the Assessing Officer to tax the cost of an asset as income. The charge to tax remains the capital gain arising from the transfer, computed in accordance with the provisions of the Act.
The Court also noted that the computation sheet reflected capital gains of ₹13,24,63,226, a figure exceeding the aggregate consideration received from the transfer of the capital assets. The Revenue did not explain how this figure had been arrived at, particularly when it did not appear in the assessment order. <FileCite ref_id=”turn3file0″ line_range_start={283} line_range_end={299} />
Bombay High Court’s Direction on Stay of Recovery
After considering the correct computation, the Court held that the total income would work out to ₹3,72,43,511 and that the tax payable, after giving credit for advance tax and self-assessment tax, was ₹32,50,541.
Twenty per cent of the tax payable worked out to ₹6,50,108. The Court therefore directed the assessee to pay ₹6,50,108 within one week and stayed recovery of the balance demand of ₹32,24,910 pending disposal of the appeal by the CIT(A), and for a further period of four weeks thereafter.
The Court also requested the CIT(A) to dispose of the appeal expeditiously, preferably by 31 March 2027.
The writ petition was disposed of in these terms. <FileCite ref_id=”turn3file0″ line_range_start = {283} line_range_end = {315} />
Important Takeaway for Taxpayers and Assessing Officers
The judgment provides an important reminder that the computation of taxable capital gains must remain anchored to the provisions of the Income-tax Act. Even where an exemption claim is disputed or denied, the amount disallowed cannot be mechanically equated with taxable income.
The decision is also a useful reference in cases where an assessment order and its accompanying computation sheet contain inconsistent figures, particularly where the computation results in capital gains exceeding the consideration received from the transfer.
However, the ruling should not be read as a final declaration that two adjoining flats qualify as one residential house under Section 54F. The High Court expressly left that issue open for adjudication in the pending appeal before the CIT(A).
The principle emerging from the decision is clear: denial of an exemption on the investment in a second flat does not justify adding the entire purchase cost of that flat to income. The taxable capital gain must be determined by applying the statutory formula prescribed under Section 54F.
The copy of the order is as under:




