
![]()
Company Converted into LLP: Can Fresh Reassessment Proceedings Be Initiated for Earlier Years? ITAT Mumbai Quashes ₹15.08 Crore Addition
DCIT v. Bhawna Computers LLP (formerly Bhawna Computers Pvt. Ltd.)
ITA No. 6127/Mum/2019 (AY 2009-10) | ITAT Mumbai | Order dated 14 September 2023
Introduction
Conversion of a private limited company into a Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) is not merely a change in the name or constitution of the business. Under the Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008, the conversion results in the dissolution of the company and the vesting of its assets, liabilities, rights and obligations in the LLP. This raises an important question under the Income-tax Act, 1961: Can the Income Tax Department initiate fresh reassessment proceedings against the successor LLP for income allegedly escaped by the erstwhile company, particularly for assessment years falling much before the conversion?
The Mumbai Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal examined this issue in DCIT v. Bhawna Computers LLP, ITA No. 6127/Mum/2019, for Assessment Year 2009-10. The Tribunal held that proceedings initiated after the conversion of the company into an LLP could not be treated as pending proceedings capable of being continued against the LLP. It further held that the Assessing Officer lacked jurisdiction to reopen and assess the income of the predecessor company for AY 2009-10 in the hands of the successor LLP.
The ruling highlights the importance of distinguishing between continuation of pending proceedings and initiation of fresh proceedings after conversion.
Facts of the Case
Bhawna Computers Pvt. Ltd., a company engaged in the business of builders and developers, was converted into Bhawna Computers LLP under the Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008, with effect from 22 March 2016.
The company had allegedly received share application money of ₹15,08,50,000 from companies based in Kolkata. According to the Revenue, these companies were operated by alleged accommodation entry providers.
For Assessment Year 2009-10, the Assessing Officer issued a notice under Section 148 of the Income-tax Act on 28 March 2016 in the name of Bhawna Computers LLP, formerly known as Bhawna Computers Pvt. Ltd. The notice was issued six days after the conversion of the company into an LLP.
The Assessing Officer proceeded to make an addition under Section 68 in respect of the alleged unexplained share application money.
The assessee challenged the reassessment proceedings, contending that the erstwhile company had ceased to exist upon conversion and that fresh proceedings initiated after the conversion could not be pursued against the LLP for an assessment year prior to the year of succession and its immediately preceding year.
The dispute eventually reached the Mumbai ITAT. <Cite refs={[“turn110935search0”]}/>
Legal Framework: Conversion of a Company into an LLP
The Tribunal examined the relevant provisions of the Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008.
Section 58 of the LLP Act
Section 58(4) provides that, upon conversion and from the date of registration:
– A limited liability partnership comes into existence by the name specified in the certificate of registration.
– All tangible and intangible property, assets, interests, rights, privileges, liabilities, obligations and the entire undertaking of the company stand transferred to and vest in the LLP.
– The erstwhile company is deemed to be dissolved and removed from the records of the Registrar of Companies.
Thus, conversion is accompanied by statutory dissolution of the company.
Clause 8 of the Third Schedule to the LLP Act
Clause 8 provides:
“All proceedings by or against the company which are pending before any Court, Tribunal or other authority on the date of registration may be continued, completed and enforced by or against the limited liability partnership.”
The Tribunal interpreted this provision to mean that only proceedings which were already pending on the date of registration could be continued against the LLP.
The provision does not authorise the initiation of fresh proceedings against the successor LLP after the date of conversion in respect of the predecessor company. <Cite refs={[“turn110935search0”]}/>
The Crucial Distinction: Pending Proceedings Versus Fresh Proceedings
The company was converted into an LLP on 22 March 2016.
The Tribunal noted that proceedings which were pending against the company as on that date could be continued against the LLP. However, the reassessment notice for AY 2009-10 was issued on 28 March 2016, after the date of conversion.
Therefore, the reassessment proceedings for AY 2009-10 were not pending on the date of registration of the LLP. They were initiated after the erstwhile company had ceased to exist.
The Tribunal observed that the LLP Act permits continuation of pending proceedings, but does not permit fresh proceedings to be initiated against the successor LLP after conversion for the predecessor company’s earlier years.
This distinction became decisive in the case.
Section 170(2): Restriction on Assessment in the Hands of the Successor
Section 170 of the Income-tax Act deals with succession to business otherwise than on death.
Under Section 170(2), where the predecessor cannot be found, the assessment of the income of the previous year in which succession took place and the previous year immediately preceding it may be made on the successor.
The assessee contended that the erstwhile company, having been statutorily dissolved and struck off from the records of the Registrar of Companies, could be regarded as a predecessor which “cannot be found”.
The Tribunal examined the statutory scheme and held that the successor LLP could not be assessed for the predecessor company’s income for years falling beyond the scope of Section 170(2).
In the present case, the year of succession was AY 2016-17. The immediately preceding assessment year was AY 2015-16.
The reassessment proceedings concerned AY 2009-10, which was far earlier than the permissible period.
Accordingly, the Tribunal held that the Assessing Officer lacked jurisdiction to reopen and assess the income of the predecessor company for AY 2009-10 in the hands of the LLP. <Cite refs={[“turn110935search0”]}/>
Tribunal’s Decision
The Mumbai ITAT held that:
1. On conversion of a private limited company into an LLP, the company is deemed to be dissolved and removed from the records of the Registrar of Companies.
2. All assets, liabilities, rights and obligations of the company vest in the successor LLP.
3. Only proceedings pending on the date of registration of the LLP can be continued against the LLP under Clause 8 of the Third Schedule to the LLP Act.
4. Reassessment proceedings initiated after the date of conversion cannot be treated as pending proceedings.
5. Section 170(2) restricts the assessment of the predecessor’s income in the hands of the successor to the year of succession and the immediately preceding year, where the predecessor cannot be found.
6. The Assessing Officer lacked jurisdiction to reopen and assess the predecessor company’s income for AY 2009-10 in the hands of the LLP.
Consequently, the Tribunal quashed the reassessment order for AY 2009-10. The assessee’s appeal was partly allowed, while the Revenue’s appeal was dismissed. <Cite refs={[“turn110935search0”]}/>
Important Takeaways for Taxpayers
The decision is significant for businesses which have undergone conversion from a private limited company into an LLP.
1. Conversion results in statutory dissolution
A company converted into an LLP ceases to exist as a company from the date of registration of the LLP.
2. Pending proceedings and fresh proceedings are different
The LLP may continue proceedings which were pending against the company on the date of conversion. However, fresh proceedings initiated after conversion cannot automatically be treated as pending proceedings.
3. Section 170(2) imposes a jurisdictional restriction
Where the predecessor cannot be found, the successor cannot be assessed without regard to the statutory restriction concerning the year of succession and the immediately preceding year.
4. Earlier assessment years require careful scrutiny
A reassessment notice issued against an LLP for an assessment year much earlier than the year of succession may be vulnerable to challenge, depending on the statutory conditions and facts.
5. Conversion documents and dates are crucial
The certificate of registration, date of conversion, date of notice and assessment year involved may determine whether proceedings were pending on the date of conversion or were initiated subsequently.
Conclusion
The decision in DCIT v. Bhawna Computers LLP reinforces the principle that the statutory consequences of conversion cannot be ignored by the Income Tax Department.
The dissolution of the predecessor company and the vesting of its undertaking in the successor LLP do not mean that the Revenue can initiate fresh reassessment proceedings against the LLP for every earlier assessment year of the erstwhile company.
The Tribunal’s interpretation of Section 170(2) of the Income-tax Act, read with Section 58 and Clause 8 of the Third Schedule to the LLP Act, places an important jurisdictional limitation on such proceedings.
The key principle emerging from the ruling is that continuation of pending proceedings is legally distinct from initiation of fresh proceedings after conversion. The successor LLP cannot be assessed for the predecessor company’s earlier years beyond the statutory scope of Section 170(2).
The copy of the order is as under:




